Tara Moore/Getty Images

The Rise of the Smartphone Era

Everywhere you look, in hallways, lunch tables, and classrooms, heads are tilted down towards glowing screens. In 2010, the average teen did not carry a front-facing camera in their pocket. By 2023, 94 percent did. Poor mental health in teens from around the world began to rise dramatically, leaving everyone wondering why. Jonathan Haidt’s bestselling book, The Anxious Generation, explores theories for the causes of these rising issues. He found that the main perpetrator was social media. While other factors, such as academic pressure and global instability, may contribute to mental health struggles, the timing of smartphone adoption suggests technology plays a significant role. New apps continue to emerge, and social expectations grow more intense. According to Education Week, “teens spent an average of about five hours on their smartphones per day, nearly two hours of which was spent on social media.” These jarring statistics highlight the importance of regulation and self-control within the smartphone world. When faced with constant temptation, it can be incredibly difficult to focus on tasks and remain present in the real world. Freshman Ava Gomez said, “I’ll open my phone to check one message, and suddenly 20 minutes are gone. It makes homework take way longer than it should.” Through four key norms, Haidt encourages his readers to take control of their lives by offering suggestions that help teenagers progress through the most crucial stages of their lives.

Haidt’s Four Norms for a Healthier Childhood

Published in 2024, The Anxious Generation  introduces four key norms that parents and teens are encouraged to enforce: 

1. No smartphones before high school
2. No social media before 16
3. Phone-free schools from bell to bell
4. More independence, free play, and responsibility in the real world

A Growing Mental Health Crisis

However, the reality looks very different. Unfortunately, very few people follow these guidelines. Consequently, many teens and young adults report feeling lonely, hopeless, and disconnected. As stated by the National Institute of Mental Health, around 5 million U.S adolescents (ages 12-17) experienced at least one major depressive episode in 2021. When comparing these percentages to earlier statistics, the change is drastic and apparent. 

Why Girls Are Affected Most

Further research supports this trend. According to the National Library of Medicine, “Daly(2) found that rates of depression increased from 2009 to 2019 among both girls and boys, but the percentage change was larger for girls (12.0%) than for boys (3.7%).” Pairing this with Haidt’s research, this increase is due to the emergence of social media and the development of the iPhone’s front-facing camera. The rise of selfie culture has made appearance-based comparison a daily habit for teens, especially girls. With the rise of filters, editing, and constant photo posting, many feel pressured to look perfect all the time. To combat this, schools and families can start by encouraging healthier phone habits and helping teens set boundaries that protect their mental well-being.

The Constant Pressure of Notifications

Another major factor contributing to teen anxiety is constant interruption. A 2023 study by C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital found that teens receive about 240 daily notifications from various apps. Over time, smartphones switched from a dream to a necessity. In an average teen’s day, this might include receiving notifications while driving, eating, taking a test, or even sleeping. According to Statista, a 2023 survey of teens found that 94 percent owned a smartphone. This illustrates the drastic effect of these 240 notifications. Creating feelings of stress, anxiety, and a feeling of being “on call” 24/7, effectively highlighting Haidt’s conclusion that phones pull teens away from real-world experiences. Mariana Pabon Rizzo described it, saying, “If I don’t answer messages fast enough, people assume I’m mad or ignoring them. It’s like you always have to be ‘on,’ even when you’re tired.”

The Hidden Cost of Comparison Culture

Beyond digital interruption, social media platforms play a major role in self-esteem. Platforms encourage comparisons of looks, lifestyles, and popularity, leaving little room for introspective growth. Unfortunately, social media only provides viewers with the “highlight reel” of life. Avoiding difficult topics and unproductive days, it creates a false sense of perfection that developing minds strive to achieve. I noticed this in my own life when I watched others post vlogs, woke up at 4 am, and went to the gym immediately. I found myself questioning why I couldn’t achieve that, then realized the lifestyle just doesn’t fit my routine. This moment made me realize how easily social media can turn everyday goals into impossible standards.

Losing Real-World Connection

The problem goes deeper than self-esteem. Not only do platforms create a false reality, but they also keep their users from properly experiencing the real one. Real independence has steadily decreased. According to Ensora Health, “when people constantly check their phones for updates or notifications, they spend less time engaging with the world around them. This reduces the chances of forming meaningful relationships or having healthy conversations with people in person, leading to feelings of isolation and loneliness.” When real-world opportunities begin to shrink, teens often turn to their phones to ease boredom and satisfy desires. The truth is that social media isn’t true social interaction. To feel surrounded by love and friendship, we need a real human connection.

Not All Screen Time Is Negative

There are benefits to acknowledging the positive sides of social media as well. Although there are major downsides to the unregulated use of technology, when used properly, social media can foster community, connection, and creativity. The issue isn’t social media itself; it is the poor use of it. Freshman Jada McDonald said she enjoys finding inspiring videos on her feed. “I actually love trying new recipes that I find on Instagram with my mom. It’s a great way for us to bond, and we have officially mastered banana bread.” This shows that social media shouldn’t be an idol or an anchor; it should be a source of imagination and inspiration. While social media has benefits, most teens aren’t using it in this way.

A Call for Healthier Boundaries

Ultimately, it isn’t a coincidence that teen anxiety and depression rose at the exact moments our lives moved onto screens. As Haidt argues, we were handed powerful technology long before anyone understood its mental impact. Although social media isn’t going anywhere, we can still cultivate healthier boundaries. Schools, homes, and daily routines should be safe environments. Growing up online has reshaped how teens see themselves, connect with others, and develop within the world. If today’s teens are the “Anxious Generation,” then turning off notifications or leaving our phones in our backpacks during class could be the first steps toward feeling less overwhelmed. If we want a generation that is confident, connected, and resilient, we must redesign how teens interact with technology.