Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

William Frost, Staff Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






In January, Hawaii suffered from a false missile alert. James Sean Shields and his girlfriend, Brenda Reichel, sued the state of Hawaii for “inducing a heart attack” during the false alert. When did this suit come up? December 2nd. According to Shields’ doctor, John S. MacGregor, the warning was a “substantial contributing factor in causing the heart attack.” Shields claims to have proof of heart damage verified by multiple doctors.

Since the lawsuit began, the defense has questioned Mr. Shields’ possible predisposition towards heart disease, and some of the holes in his testimony. For example, he and Ms. Reichel reported considering their lives forfeit already, but Mr. Shields was still rushed to the hospital once his heart complications started before they became aware of the all-clear signal that was sent 38 minutes after the accident. This implies that the hopeless trauma felt by Mr. Shields was not as extreme as he claimed. The case is currently being reviewed by a judge in the state’s lower courts.

The suit calls into question some intriguing questions about the accountability of states to their citizens. If states are liable to be sued if they trigger a false alarm, emergency services may be more lethargic in their responses, perhaps leading to citizens not being warned in the case of a real emergency. However, other arguments have surfaced concerning the plight of victims of false alarms and the financial burden that many people face as part of treatment for stress-induced injuries. The balance between safety and accountability is in the balance with proponents of both sides providing viable arguments.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
About the Writer
William Frost, Staff Writer

William Frost (12) is a senior with an abiding love of history and writing. He hopes to use his passion to help write enlightening articles for the Shark...

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

    National News

    Kamala Harris – Qualified or Unqualified?

  • Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

    National News

    “ISIS Bride” Seeks Return to US, Blocked by Trump Administration

  • Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

    National News

    The Spinning Ice Disk of Maine

  • Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

    National News

    Baby Found In Amazon Warehouse Bathroom

  • Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

    National News

    Sears Plans to Reconstruct?

  • Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

    National News

    Third Cat Found With Black Plague

  • Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

    National News

    Jayme Closs Found Alive, Suspect Arrested

  • Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

    National News

    License Plates Recalled for Racism

  • Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

    National News

    The 2018 Midterm Elections

  • Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm

    National News

    The Aftermath of Hurricane Michael

Navigate Right

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Man Sues Hawaii for False Alarm